Court Order in Favour of Clients: Challenging the Unlawful Gatekeeping Conduct of Department of Home Affairs Officials

March 06, 2025

De Saude Darbandi

We are very pleased to share a significant victory in a recent case involving visa and residency applications at the Department of Home Affairs in Cape Town. Our clients faced unfair delays, rejections, and were turned away without their applications being processed. Through diligent effort, we successfully challenged this wrongful rejection and obtained a judicial review order.

This ruling not only allows our clients to proceed with their applications, but it also establishes a clearer path for others seeking to file at this office.

This victory reaffirms our commitment to providing exceptional legal representation, particularly in the complex areas of immigration and citizenship law. In this instance, the Cape Town Department of Home Affairs unlawfully refused to accept several applications without valid grounds, causing unnecessary setbacks. The court’s decision sets an important precedent for how such matters should be handled moving forward, ensuring fairness and accountability in the application process.

Court’s Ruling:

The court found that the refusal to accept applications was unlawful and ultra vires the relevant legislation.

The Department is directed to accept and process the applications of our clients.

The Department is ordered to pay the costs of the application.

Implications:

This ruling ensures that applicants in Cape Town will no longer face unjust rejections, meaning the refusal to accept applications for onward transmission to Pretoria without proper reasoning, paving the way for a more transparent process.

This victory is a testament to the dedication of our legal team, but more importantly, it’s a win for the rights of the individuals we fight for.

A huge thank you to our counsel (Advocate David Simonsz) for his unwavering commitment and to the judge for their fair decision-making, which has set an important precedent for justice in immigration matters.

Full Judgement here